The same discourse in preserved in Sanskrit in the Lalita-vistara, as the Dharma-cakra-pravartana-sūtra.
“There are these
two extremes, monks, that one who has gone forth ought not to descend
to; namely:
being joined,
through a life of sensual luxury, to sense desires, which is low,
vulgar, worldly, not very noble, meaningless, not conducive to
spiritual growth in the long term, leading neither to
world-weariness, nor to dispassion, nor to cessation, nor to deep
knowledge, nor to the complete awakening of saṁbodhi, nor to the
release from suffering of nirvāṇa;
and this, which also
is not the middle path (amadhyamā pratipad):
devotion to
privation of one's own body, which is painful, meaningless, painful
in the present and having a painful consequence in the long run.
Not having
approached either of these two extremes, monks, the tathāgata
teaches the dharma solely by way of the middle path (madhyamayaiva
pratipadā), which is this:
seeing straight, thinking straight,
talking straight, true action,
making a clean living, true endeavour
, true mindfulness,
balanced stillness.
dvāv imau bhikṣavaḥ
pravrajitasyāntāvakramau,
etau ca bhikṣavo
dvāv antāv anupagamya
In these records of the Buddha's first teaching, the
middle is a practice ( Pali paṭipad = means of reaching a goal or destination, path, way, means, method, mode of progress, course, practice), or a path (Sanskrit pratipad = the path to be walked, the right path). And the two extremes which the middle way does not approach are sensuality and extreme self-denial, or hedonism and asceticism.
This first teaching of the middle way is tailored to the Buddha's first audience, his former companions in the kind of severe ascetic practices which (as described in Buddhacarita Canto 12), the bodhisattva found to fail the pragmatic test of truth -- they didn't work.
In the fourth discourse, delivered to the self-made men of Māgadha, the Buddha will again speak of teaching the Dharma by way of the middle. But in this case he will describe the two extremes that are not approached as the eternity-view and the annihilation-view.
This first teaching of the middle way is tailored to the Buddha's first audience, his former companions in the kind of severe ascetic practices which (as described in Buddhacarita Canto 12), the bodhisattva found to fail the pragmatic test of truth -- they didn't work.
In the fourth discourse, delivered to the self-made men of Māgadha, the Buddha will again speak of teaching the Dharma by way of the middle. But in this case he will describe the two extremes that are not approached as the eternity-view and the annihilation-view.
No comments:
Post a Comment